Coroner warns of lack of public understanding of PAs following patient death

A coroner has warned there is a lack of public understanding over the role of physician associates (PAs) after the death of a patient whose family believed they had been seen by a doctor.

(c) Wesley Tingey/Unsplash

(c) Wesley Tingey/Unsplash

Pamela Marking, 77, who died in February 2024, had been suffering from severe abdominal problems but was disagnosed as having suffered a nosebleed by a PA.

The inquest heard Marking had to be re-admitted to East Surrey Hospital after having been discharged without a 'medical review or direct medical supervision', the MailOnline reported.

She underwent surgery but died within 48 hours following issues with her anaesthetic.

Coroner Dr Karen Henderson warned the unfettered use of PAs could lead to more deaths, adding: ‘This blurring of roles without public knowledge and understanding of the role of a physician associate has the potential to devalue and undermine public confidence in the medical profession.'

A Department of Health and Social Care spokesperson said: ‘This is a tragic case and our deepest sympathies are with Pamela Marking's family and friends. 

‘The secretary of state has launched an independent review into physician and anaesthesia associate professions to establish the facts and make sure we get the right people in the right places providing the right care.

‘Regulation of PAs and AAs by the General Medical Council began in December to ensure patient safety and professional accountability.'

An NHS spokesperson said: ‘NHS England extends its deepest sympathies to the family and friends of Pamela Marking - we are carefully considering the Prevention of Future Deaths Report sent to us by HM Coroner and will respond in due course.

‘The NHS has always been clear that physician associates are not replacements for doctors and should only practice with appropriate medical supervision, but there remain legitimate concerns about the roles and so the Leng Review will gather insight from across the NHS to ensure they are being used appropriately to deliver safe care for patients.'

Surrey and Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust offered its ‘deepest sympathies' to Marking's family and pledged to learn lessons from the case, adding: ‘Our Emergency Department follows Royal College of Emergency Medicine guidelines and operates a multidisciplinary rota, which includes Tier 2 clinicians such as resident doctors, advanced care practitioners (ACP), and physician associates (PA). Physician associates follow a nationally recognised programme of training and work within a very specific scope of practice under the direct supervision of a consultant, as was the case here. All of our physician associates wear designated scrubs with their job title, physician associate lanyards, and use the recommended introduction of their role when meeting patients. We have also introduced a visual guide clearly illustrating the different uniforms, roles and responsibilities within our Emergency Department.'

GP practices embrace technology to improve patient access

GP practices embrace technology to improve patient access

By Liz Wells 24 April 2025

GPs are providing millions more appointments to people in England and better access through upgraded technology, new data shows.

Liverpool trust ordered to pay nurse over £200k for failing to implement timely reasonable adjustments

By Liz Wells 23 April 2025

Mersey Care NHS Foundation Trust has been ordered to pay more than £200,000 to a community nurse after an employment tribunal found it failed to implement ti...

BMA considers next move after 'disappointing' PA ruling

By Liz Wells 17 April 2025

The BMA is considering its next steps after the 'disappointing' ruling from the High Court over its case against the GMC for blurring the lines between docto...


Popular articles by Lee Peart